Author = حسین رحیمی کلور
Entrepreneurship

Providing an Enhanced Multi-Agent Artificial Intelligence Model to Improve the Efficiency of Banking Services Marketing

Volume 6, Issue 3, Autumn 2026

https://doi.org/10.22034/jvcbm.2026.578225.1717

Nagham Khalid Abdulameer Alrubaye, Hosein Rahimi Koluor, Mohammad Bashokouh Ajirloo, Ghasem Zarei

Abstract The aim of this research is to design, develop, and evaluate a Multi-Agent Artificial Intelligence (MAS) framework that significantly increases the efficiency of banking services marketing processes by utilizing a distributed architecture. This study specifically focuses on operational data and digital transformation challenges at Rafidin Bank in Iraq. This study uses the applied-developmental research methodology and intelligent systems modeling. The proposed framework consists of four independent key agents: Data Analysis Agent (DAA), Offer Personalization Agent (PA), Campaign Execution Agent (CEA), and Coordinator Agent. The agents interact and collaborate with each other through algorithms such as behavioral clustering, reinforcement learning for offer optimization, and linear programming for budget allocation. The effectiveness of the framework was measured through simulation on Rafidin Bank’s historical data and by comparing financial and operational metrics (ROMI, conversion rate, and CAC) with traditional approaches. The results indicated the high effectiveness of the MAS framework in optimizing marketing processes. This framework was able to: Increase Return on Marketing Investment (ROMI) by 36.1%. Improve the Conversion Rate of target customers by 46.4%. Reduce Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) by 29.1%, which is due to precise targeting and optimal channel management. These improvements are the result of the system's ability to make prescriptive decisions and execute operations in a distributed and real-time manner.

Business Management

Modeling Interactive Content Marketing: The Role of Digital Content in Influencing Consumer Buying Decisions in Iraq

Volume 6, Issue 2, Summer 2026, Pages 69-92

https://doi.org/10.22034/jvcbm.2026.580937.1743

Ahmed Salam Ali nukhailawi, Hosein Rahimi Koluor, Bahman KHodapanah, Mohamad Bashokouh Ajirlou

Abstract The purpose of the present study is to design an interactive content marketing model with an emphasis on its role in shaping the purchasing decisions of digital consumers in Iraq. In terms of purpose, this research is applicable, and in terms of execution, it is qualitative; the adopted strategy is exploratory, and the method utilized is thematic analysis. The research population consists of 21 faculty members and experts in the field of digital and interactive marketing in Iraq, selected based on purposive sampling and the data saturation technique. The data collection tool is semi-structured in-depth interviews. For data analysis, thematic analysis and MAXQDA software were employed. The findings of the thematic network analysis revealed 6 organizing themes, 14 basic themes, and 58 primary codes as the components and categories of interactive content marketing with an emphasis on its role in shaping digital consumers’ purchasing decisions. The (organizing) themes were presented in 6 dimensions: strategic factors, consumer factors, brand factors, consumer value-creation attitude, content personalization strategy, and responsiveness and feedback. The results indicated that interactive content marketing, as an emerging and effective strategy, plays a significant and influential role in shaping and strengthening the purchasing decisions of digital consumers.
Introduction
In the current digital age, social networks have become one of the primary hubs for interaction, communication, and information exchange between businesses and consumers (Zamani et al., 2022). These platforms are not only used as a base for marketing and advertising but have fundamentally transformed the nature of marketing communications through their interactive capabilities (Bazi et al., 2020). Meanwhile, the concept of “Interactive Content Marketing” has emerged as a novel and effective strategy, capturing the attention of researchers and marketing professionals. Unlike traditional methods that were largely based on one-way message dissemination, this type of marketing emphasizes creating a two-way dialogue, encouraging active audience participation, and crafting personalized experiences.
On the other hand, the consumer purchasing decision process, especially in the digital context, has undergone significant transformations (Lou & Xie, 2021). Today, digital consumers go through complex stages of information searching, option comparison, evaluating other users’ opinions, and interacting with brands in online spaces—particularly social networks—before taking action to buy. This process is not a simple linear sequence but rather a cyclical and dynamic path where the customer moves repeatedly between stages of awareness, consideration, evaluation, and action (Chang et al., 2025). This necessitates a deeper understanding of the factors influencing the formation of these decisions.
Despite the increasing importance of interaction in virtual space, few studies have specifically examined the role of “interactive content” in shaping purchasing decisions within the context of developing markets like Iraq (Bianchi & Andrews, 2023). One of the concepts that marketers currently focus on regarding consumer consumption behavior is the creation of pleasant experiences and their impact on consumer behavior. Creating diverse experiences as a vital element in marketing strategies can create value and lead to a competitive advantage (Holliman & Rowley, 2024).
The process of online shopping involves purchasing goods directly from the seller without intermediaries, which can be defined as the activity of buying and selling goods via the internet. Online shopping transactions provide customers with a variety of products and services, allowing them to compare these products with those of other intermediaries and select the best option (Daroch et al., 2021). In the Middle East region, and specifically in Iraq, the rapid expansion of internet penetration and smartphone usage has led to the emergence of a massive population of digital consumers who perform a significant portion of their daily activities—including searching for product information, interacting with brands, and shopping—through social networks.
The Iraqi market, with its young and tech-savvy population, provides a dynamic environment for studying digital phenomena. Specific socio-cultural characteristics of this market, including the importance of word-of-mouth communication, trust in personal recommendations, and the strong role of family and community in decision-making, have made the potential of social networks and interactive content in influencing consumer behavior highly significant in this country (We Are Social & Hootsuite, 2024). Therefore, the present study seeks to answer the following scientific question: What is the interactive content marketing model with an emphasis on its role in shaping the purchasing decisions of digital consumers in Iraq?
Theoretical Framework
Interactive Marketing
Interactive marketing is an innovative form of marketing in which audiences can engage and communicate with your content. In this approach, a brand provides a relevant and appropriate response based on the specific actions and movements of each customer and audience member. This method allows brands to act more creatively and tell more compelling stories, thereby attracting a larger audience. Unlike outbound marketing methods, interactive marketing creates an environment where customers and the brand can engage in a two-way dialogue (Lufkin, 2024).
Zhu et al. (2026) investigated the design of a content marketing process model aimed at strengthening customer purchase intention. The results of this research indicated that to achieve modern marketing based on social media—characterized by two-way interactive dialogues and feedback reception (a many-to-many communication system)—organizations should prioritize these elements in their information dissemination, advertising, and health tourism marketing programs.
Ahmadi alinoudehi et al. (2026) analyzed the dimensions and components of digital transformation management based on Artificial Intelligence (AI). The results of their study indicated that AI-based digital transformation management is designed within four overarching categories: “contextual requirements,” “digital infrastructure,” “digital transformation management process,” and “organizational capital.” These include 12 organizing categories: “ethical requirements,” “cultural requirements,” “organizational requirements,” “hard digital infrastructure,” “soft digital infrastructure,” “digital transformation management process,” “digital transformation planning,” “prototyping,” “learning,” “human capital,” “process capital,” “structural capital,” and “social capital,” comprising a total of 73 basic categories.
Methodology
In terms of objective, this research is applicable, and regarding its execution, it is qualitative. The adopted strategy is exploratory, and the chosen method is thematic analysis. The research population consists of 21 faculty members and experts in the field of digital and interactive marketing in Iraq, selected through purposive sampling utilizing the data saturation technique. The data collection instrument employed is semi-structured in-depth interviews.
Research Findings
Data analysis was conducted through the thematic analysis method and MAXQDA software. The findings from the thematic network analysis identified 6 organizing themes, 14 basic themes, and 58 primary codes as the components and categories of interactive content marketing, emphasizing its role in shaping the purchasing decisions of digital consumers. The organizing themes were categorized into six dimensions: strategic factors, consumer factors, brand factors, consumer value-creation attitude, content personalization strategy, and responsiveness and feedback. The results demonstrated that interactive content marketing, as an emerging and effective strategy, plays a vital and influential role in shaping and reinforcing the purchasing decisions of digital consumers.
Conclusion
The present study was conducted with the aim of designing an interactive content marketing model, emphasizing its role in shaping the purchasing decisions of digital consumers in Iraq. The results obtained from these findings are consistent with the research of Zhu et al. (2026), Ahmadi Alinoudehi et al. (2026), Jalalzadeh et al. (2025), Abolhasani Abrghan & Dadash Karimi (2025), Bagher Mosavi & Fadai (2024), Shakeri (2024), and Zamani et al. (2022). Notably, Zhu et al. (2026) demonstrated that to achieve modern marketing based on social media—characterized by two-way interactive dialogues and feedback reception (a many-to-many communication system)—organizations must prioritize these elements in their information dissemination, advertising, and health tourism marketing programs.
Based on the research results, it is suggested that to reach the optimal state of marketing and customer loyalty, organizations should involve their employees across various fields and departments. The company should supervise and participate in business operations and the mapping of employees’ professional futures, while simultaneously pursuing competitive excellence in its programs.

Business Management

From Network to Innovation: Designing an Entrepreneurial Network Marketing Model in the Food Industry

Volume 6, Issue 1, Spring 2026, Pages 377-397

https://doi.org/10.22034/jvcbm.2026.577762.1715

WADULLAH AL-MANSOORI, Hosein Rahimi Koluor, Bahman KHodapanah, Mohammad bashokouh Ajirlou

Abstract The purpose of the present study is to design a suitable network marketing model with an entrepreneurial approach in the food industry. This research is applicable in purpose, and qualitative in nature. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with experts in the fields of marketing, entrepreneurship, and the food industry, and analyzed using thematic analysis. The findings led to the identification of a set of basic, organizing, and ten overarching themes, presented within a coherent model. The results indicate that success in this ecosystem depends primarily on the intelligent integration of “cultural–tribal authenticity” with “modern entrepreneurial and digital capabilities.” Themes such as adaptive–religious marketing strategies, tribal network dynamics, and governance based on trust and commitment were identified as the key pillars of social acceptance and market penetration. The findings also highlight that entrepreneurial orientation, knowledge management, and digital transformation are the main drivers for enhancing market performance and creating sustainable value. Ultimately, this research offers an operational framework illustrating how the synergy between traditional structures of trust and modern technologies can lead to resilience and competitive advantage in Iraq’s food industry. This model can serve as a roadmap for entrepreneurs and policymakers aiming to develop network marketing in similar markets.
Introduction
The present era is the age of information and networking. Information network technologies have influenced every corner of the world and have changed the way people receive and distribute information. Companies use new network technologies to transform their business philosophy, commercial organization, and business practices (Davijani et al., 2025). Network marketing is a new phenomenon that aligns with the development of network technologies and social changes in the network age. It is a business model that offers an exceptional opportunity for individuals who want to start a business but lack capital. Some refer to it as helping people conduct their own business (Gholami, 2021).
Over the years, various deceptive practices carried out under the name of network marketing have caused the global community to lose its trust in the industry. Network marketing organizations are composed of groups of individuals who interact and communicate through relationships built on trust. When society gradually loses trust, the organization will not be successful (Heidari Haratemeh et al., 2023). Therefore, taking actions to improve trust levels is critical for the sustainability of this industry and is considered a serious and essential matter for all network marketing professionals.
The food industry has become an inseparable part of human life and one of the most important factors in economic and social development worldwide. As one of the largest and most tangible global industries, it has attracted significant interest from investors toward entrepreneurship in this sector. Today, the economic dimensions of the global food industry have expanded greatly and hold potential for further development. In every country, substantial annual revenue is generated for stakeholders in this industry, which has further increased attention to it.
Accordingly, the present study aims to answer the fundamental question: What is an appropriate network marketing model with an entrepreneurial approach for the food industry in Iraq?
Theoretical Foundations
Network Marketing
Network marketing refers to communication processes in which individuals, groups, or companies use social networks and interpersonal connections to introduce and promote their products. This type of marketing typically operates based on networks of human relationships and direct or indirect interactions among individuals (Lu et al., 2024).
Entrepreneurship
Entrepreneurship is the process of identifying and exploiting new opportunities to create innovative businesses. This activity enables entrepreneurs to recognize existing problems and pursue new and valuable solutions through risk‑taking and creativity (Doozandeh Ziabari et al., 2024). One of the prominent characteristics of entrepreneurs is their ability to cope with uncertainties and market challenges. These individuals establish businesses using limited resources that can generate significant economic and social impact (Norouzi Seyed Hossini et al., 2024).
Alizadeh Seyghalan et al. (2025) examined key factors in entrepreneurial opportunities and challenges and proposed a model for improving entrepreneurial performance. Their results showed that network marketing entrepreneurship offers considerable opportunities for market entry and meeting unmet needs, but it also faces challenges in adapting to rapid market changes and ensuring job security.
Ajali et al. (2024) investigated the identification and ranking of factors influencing the creation of viral marketing behavior among customers. The findings indicated that 2 factors, 6 components, and 27 indicators were extracted based on the theoretical foundations of the study; among which, the organizational factor ranked first with a score of 0.702, while the external factor ranked second with a score of 0.269. Therefore, it can be stated that 70.2% of the intention toward viral marketing is shaped by organizational factors, while brand credibility accounts for 7.8% of the total intention toward viral marketing.
Research Method
This study is applicable in terms of purpose, and qualitative in nature and methodology. Given the exploratory nature of the topic and the necessity of identifying the deeper dimensions of entrepreneurial network marketing within the specific context of Iraq’s food industry, the thematic analysis strategy was employed. The primary data‑collection tool in this research consisted of semi‑structured interviews. The interview protocol was designed to explore various dimensions of experiences, challenges, and strategies related to network marketing within Iraq’s commercial ecosystem. The aim of these interviews was to identify the components and key factors influencing the success of entrepreneurial network marketing.
The collected data were processed and analyzed using thematic analysis to extract the main concepts and components. In the quantitative phase, the model derived from the qualitative analysis was tested and validated through a questionnaire developed for this purpose, using responses gathered from members of active networks in the food industry.
Research Findings
The research findings indicate that success in the network marketing of Iraq’s food industry hinges on the intelligent integration of cultural-tribal authenticities with the novel capabilities of entrepreneurship and digitalization. This model, by relying on knowledge management and adaptive religious strategies, provides a platform for creating sustainable value, enhancing competitive performance, and increasing customer loyalty. In essence, the synergy between traditional trust structures and modern technologies is considered the fundamental cornerstone for resilience and penetration in this volatile market.
Discussion and Conclusion
The results indicated a strong relationship between the requirements for maintaining cultural authenticity, adaptive-religious marketing strategies, socio-tribal network dynamics, and digital transformation. This finding suggests that attention to preserving cultural authenticity can play a key role in guiding strategies and enhancing the digital transformation process. These results align with the studies by Alizadeh Seyghalan et al. (2025) and Ajali & Kargar Zanjani (2024), which emphasize that considering the cultural and local context increases the effectiveness of network marketing strategies.
Regarding adaptive-religious marketing strategies, a moderate-level relationship was observed with socio-tribal network dynamics and digital transformation. This suggests that these strategies alone may not have a strong impact on network behavior and digital transformation and likely exert their effects through interaction with other factors. This finding is consistent with the results of Heidari Haratemeh (2023) and Doozandeh Ziabari et al. (2024), who state that adaptive marketing should be employed alongside other tools and network management for optimal effectiveness.
Entrepreneurial orientation was identified as a key variable in the research, showing a strong or above-average relationship with most variables, including marketing strategies, network dynamics, network governance, food industry dynamics, knowledge management, and network marketing performance. These results highlight the pivotal role of entrepreneurial orientation in activating networks and strengthening organizational capacities, aligning with studies by Wong & Nasir (2022) and Guerola-Navarro et al. (2024), which indicate that entrepreneurial orientation can facilitate the implementation of marketing strategies and digital transformation.
In the domain of network governance, its relationships with entrepreneurial orientation and digital transformation were strong, while its connection with network dynamics was at a moderate level. This pattern suggests that for network governance to effectively impact digital transformation, it must be combined with entrepreneurial motivations and behaviors, and network management alone is insufficient. The findings are consistent with the study by Monferrer et al. (2022), which highlights the importance of synchronizing network governance with dynamic capabilities to enhance performance and innovation.
The results showed that food industry dynamics have a strong relationship with value creation, value acquisition, and knowledge management, and demonstrated an above-average connection with network marketing performance. These findings emphasize the significant role of food industry dynamics in the value chain and knowledge transfer within organizations, aligning with the results of Bazoukar & Bagheri (2025) and Davijani et al. (2023), who stress the importance of innovation processes and social entrepreneurship in network development.
Furthermore, knowledge management exhibited a strong relationship with digital transformation and an above-average relationship with network marketing performance, while the relationship between network marketing performance and digital transformation was at a moderate level. This indicates that effective knowledge management and information transfer play a crucial role in the success of network marketing and advancing digital transformation, as also emphasized in the studies by Ebrahimi et al. (2022) and Lu et al. (2024).
Overall, the analysis of the discovered hypotheses suggests that entrepreneurial orientation, network governance, and food industry dynamics are the key factors with the most significant impact on digital transformation and network marketing performance, while variables such as adaptive marketing strategies and requirements for maintaining cultural authenticity play a reinforcing and mediating role. This analysis underscores that a combination of entrepreneurial orientation, knowledge management, network governance, and food industry dynamics is essential for success in network marketing and digital transformation.
Based on the research findings, the following practical suggestions are presented:
· Organizations should meticulously consider the cultural and religious characteristics of their target audience when designing their marketing strategies to enhance customer engagement and acceptance.
· To strengthen social and tribal networks, marketing programs and activities must be designed in compliance with cultural values and traditions to increase member participation.
· The preservation of cultural authenticity should be considered a key factor in digital transformation projects, ensuring that technologies and innovations are compatible with the community’s cultural context, thereby increasing user adoption.